In this article
You have accepted a new offer. When you hand in your resignation, your manager says: "Stay, and we'll give you 15% more." That is a counter offer, and many people hesitate at this moment. Here is what we have seen helping candidates through job moves.
Why companies make counter offers
- Hiring a replacement takes time and money, and training a new person takes longer.
- Your projects or clients would be hard to hand over.
- The team is stretched and others might follow you.
- Your manager does not want to look as if they lost a good person.
Most of these reasons are about the company's needs, not a fresh view of your value.
The risks of accepting
- The reasons you wanted to leave are still there. More money does not fix limited growth, a difficult manager or a poor culture.
- Trust changes. The company now knows you were ready to leave, which can affect promotions and key projects.
- The raise may be brought forward. It can replace the increases you would have had over the next year or two.
- Your reputation with the new employer. Backing out after accepting can follow you in a small industry.
Five questions to ask yourself
- Why did I start looking? Does this raise solve that?
- Would I have been offered this raise if I had not resigned?
- Apart from pay, has the company committed to specific changes, such as title, scope or reporting line? Are they in writing?
- Will I still want to be here in a year?
- What does the new job give me that this one never will?
If most answers point to leaving, stick with your plan.
When accepting can make sense
- Pay really was your only reason, and the new package fairly reflects your market value.
- The changes offered (promotion, new responsibilities) are specific and confirmed in writing.
- You have not yet accepted the new offer.
Declining a counter offer gracefully
Thank you, and the company, for the offer to stay, and for your guidance over the past few years. I've valued my time here.
After thinking it over, I've decided to go ahead with the new role, as it fits my career direction more closely. I'll make sure the handover is complete during my notice period so the team is not affected.
Best regards,
Wong Siu Ming
Avoiding the situation altogether
- Be sure you want to leave before you accept a new offer.
- If pay is the only issue, try discussing it with your current employer first. See our guide on how to ask for a raise.
- Resign firmly and warmly, making it clear your decision is made.
Read more: resignation letter templates and handover checklist. Looking for your next role? Submit your CV.